Skip to content
Third-party risk management for regulated financial institutions 1 (800) 897-5810 support@vendorrisk.com

Vendor risk guide

Inherent vs residual risk for vendors

A vendor has two risk levels worth writing down: how risky the relationship is by its nature, and how risky it still is after what you and the vendor have done about it. This guide explains the difference, why both belong on the record, and how the two are kept in VendorRisk.

What inherent risk means

Inherent risk is the exposure a vendor relationship carries before any controls or mitigations are counted. It comes from what the vendor does for you, not from how well the vendor does it. A vendor that holds customer data, runs a system your operations depend on, or deals with your customers directly carries more inherent risk than one that supplies office furniture.

What residual risk means

Residual risk is what remains after controls and mitigations are taken into account. The vendor has controls of its own, such as security practices, insurance and a continuity plan, and you have yours, such as contract terms and monitoring.

Inherent risk changes when the relationship changes. Residual risk moves more often, coming down when a finding is fixed or a new safeguard goes in.

Why a program records both

One level on its own hides half the picture. A vendor rated Low could be a minor supplier, or a critical one with strong controls. A single rating cannot tell them apart.

  • Inherent risk tells you how much scrutiny a vendor deserves.
  • Residual risk tells you whether the relationship is acceptable as it stands. A vendor with high inherent risk and strong controls may be a sound choice.
  • The gap between the two shows whether oversight is working. Where the two levels are still the same on a critical vendor, more attention is due.

How VendorRisk keeps the two levels

With residual risk turned off, a vendor has one risk level and every risk assessment form updates it. When an administrator turns residual risk on, every vendor gets a second level, so the vendor record shows its inherent risk level and, separately, its residual risk level.

Each risk assessment form then declares which level it drives. When a form is built, the administrator chooses its risk type, inherent or residual, and the level a review calculates flows to the matching field on the vendor. One form measures baseline exposure and another, run after controls are in place, records the mitigated result, and neither overwrites the other.

The same option exists for services, software and hardware, each under its own settings.

Risk assessments →

How a level is calculated

A risk assessment template uses one of three methods: a question-and-answer form, a scoring matrix, or a level the reviewer selects by hand. Your administrator defines the risk levels, such as Low, Medium and High, and the minimum points for each. On a scored form, the point total is matched against those thresholds to give the level.

An answer can also carry a trigger that ties it directly to a risk level, so one decisive answer can set the outcome regardless of the point total. Risk assessments are completed by your own team, not by the vendor.

What happens after the level is set

Each risk level can carry its own review frequencies for risk, diligence, on-site and performance reviews, so a vendor's next review dates roll forward by the frequency of the level it lands in.

A risk assessment form can send the finished review to a committee for approval, and can use a different committee for each risk level the review calculates. Any risk question can have a remediation item raised on it, with an owner and supporting documents. Remediation raised from a risk assessment is always internal.

With residual risk on, a change to a vendor's residual level is written to the vendor's log beside its inherent level, with the date and who made it.

Risk tiering for critical vendors →

The two levels side by side

Inherent risk Residual risk
What it measures Exposure before controls and mitigations Exposure that remains after them
What it is used for Deciding how much scrutiny the vendor gets Deciding whether the relationship is acceptable as it stands
In VendorRisk The vendor's risk level, set by a form whose risk type is inherent A second level on the vendor, set by a form whose risk type is residual

Residual risk is an optional setting. With it off, each vendor has a single risk level.

Common questions

Do we have to track residual risk?
No. It is an optional setting. With it off, each vendor has one risk level and every risk assessment form updates it.
Can one assessment set both levels?
No. Each risk assessment form drives one level, inherent or residual. A program that records both uses a form for each.
Can we record inherent and residual risk for a single service or software product?
Yes. Residual risk can be turned on separately for services, software and hardware.
Is there a history of changes to a vendor's risk level?
Yes. A change to the residual risk level is recorded in the vendor's log alongside its inherent level, with a date and an author.

Related

Keep both risk levels on every vendor

Score inherent and residual risk with your own templates, and let each vendor's risk level set its review schedule.

Your Next Exam Starts Today

Build the vendor oversight program your regulators expect — before they ask for it.